Law Change Makes It Hard to Receive Compensation for Solar Developers
Law Change Makes It Hard to Receive Compensation for Solar Developers
The solar energy capacity addition has grown over 23 times in the country since 2014, a meteoric rise that tends to cover the regulatory uncertainty prevailing in the sector. Getting compensation for solar developers for additional costs incurred due to taxation policy changes becoming hard to receive.
Several taxation-related changes have qualified under Change-in-law (CIL) in the last few years. Some are law for compensation for solar developers, safeguard duty on modules, GST rate hikes, and the most recent event of Basic Customs Duty (BCD). CIL provisions in power purchase agreements provide developers with the right to recover additional capital costs incurred due to government policy changes between bidding and commissioning.
The safeguard duty was imposed on the modules for the first time in 2018, but industry sources say that most developers are still awaiting reimbursements in full. In many cases, the litigations are continuing. The story has been repeated in the case of GST hike. When it comes to seeking compensation for the 40% BCD imposition on modules, developers feel resigned to their fate.
The process of reimbursements from state-owned distribution companies (DISCOMs) is rarely straightforward, even though tax changes are considered CIL events under PPAs. “The PPA clause often mentions that regulators should declare all tax rate changes as ‘change in law’ events. However, unless the regulatory body approves and passes an order for an increase in the determined auctioned tariff, the developers can’t expect the DISCOMs to act,” a developer said.
CIL petitions filed with state regulatory bodies (SERC), quasi-judicial bodies, may take at least 18 months before a final decision is made. But usually, the time taken is much longer than that. “The merit of the petition doesn’t matter to the DISCOMs. Their objective is to ensure the order is delayed as much as possible. They achieve this by filing baseless submissions and rejoinders,” another developer said.
Even after an order is delivered, many DISCOMs go back to the Commission to seek a review. The CIL orders usually give the DISCOMs a few options for compensating the developers. The DISCOMs are either asked to pay a lump sum or convert the compensation into an annuity at a specific interest rate.
But the ordeal for the developers doesn’t end here. At least two developers confirmed that the DISCOMs falsely informed the Commission about paying the amount in order. They often pay a portion and claim that the compensation is settled. Several developers have filed complaints against DISCOM officials over the years because of this. “The entire process creates judicial ambiguities. It affects the confidence of the developers adversely,” a third developer stated.
The inordinate delay in granting compensation to developers raises the cost of capital for the company. Consequently, the developers are forced to raise more debt for operations.
Furthermore, when calculating compensation under CIL, the Commissions often consider only the cost of borrowed funds by the developer without factoring in the equity that goes with the debt. Even if DISCOMs cooperate and CIL petitions are promptly disposed of, developers have a disadvantage from the beginning.
“Generators resent the long-drawn regulatory process for CIL. While the CIL process has been considerably streamlined, it remains fraught with pain and long lead times,” Vinay Pabba, COO of Vibrant Energy, said.
Suggested Articles

Fuses & Circuit Breakers Inspection Guide for Solar PV Systems
A complete guide to inspecting fuses and circuit breakers in solar PV systems, including testing methods, fault identification, preventive maintenance, and safety checks for reliable system operation.

Solar System Grounding Conductor Size Guide
A complete guide to determining grounding conductor size for solar PV systems, ensuring safe, compliant, and reliable installations.

Solar Inverter Inspection & Maintenance Guide
A complete guide to solar inverter inspection and maintenance, including visual inspections, performance checks, fault diagnosis, cleaning, and preventive maintenance to maximize efficiency and reliability.

End of Rooftop Solar Subsidy for Industrial & Commercial Consumers: What You Need to Know
The rooftop solar subsidy for industrial and commercial consumers is coming to an end. This guide explains the implications for businesses, updated policies, and strategies to adopt solar power without relying on subsidies.

Solar Electrical Installation Toolkit: Inspection & Usage Guide
A complete guide to the electrical installation toolkit for solar installers, including inspection procedures, tool usage, and safety practices.

Why Solar Energy Makes Sense for the Healthcare Industry
Explore how the healthcare industry can leverage solar energy to reduce electricity bills, enhance reliability, and support green initiatives.

How to Check Solar PV Modules for Physical Damage
A complete guide on how to clean solar PV modules, including safe cleaning techniques, recommended tools, maintenance schedules, and best practices to maximize energy output.

Battery Maintenance for Solar PV Systems Guide
A complete guide to battery maintenance for solar PV systems, including inspection, cleaning, testing, charging, and preventive maintenance to ensure long battery life and reliable performance.